Most UK small business owners have never bought a fake review. Plenty have done something close to it without thinking twice: asked a cousin to "get the ball rolling" on a new Google profile, offered 10% off for a five-star rating, or quietly left the best testimonials on the homepage while the awkward ones sat in an inbox. Since April 2025, several of those habits carry real legal risk. This guide explains what the DMCC Act fake review rules say, what the regulator has done so far, and the practical steps a small business can take this week.
What does the DMCC Act say about fake reviews?
The CMA announced that the new consumer protection provisions were in force in April 2025, describing the Act as including "an explicit ban on the posting and commissioning of fake reviews." The detail sits in the CMA's fake reviews guidance, known as CMA208, and its short guide for businesses publishing consumer reviews, published in April 2025.
The short guide groups the banned content into three types:
- Fake reviews, meaning reviews that look or claim to be genuine but are not.
- Concealed incentivised reviews, where someone was paid or given a free benefit and that is not made clear.
- False or misleading consumer review information, which covers overall ratings, review counts, summaries and rankings, including where they are built on fake reviews.
Who do the fake review rules apply to?
According to the CMA's short guide, that includes websites, social media, search services, online marketplaces, specialist review sites, trader recommendation platforms and even print. A plumber with a "What our customers say" page and a salon embedding a review widget are both in scope.
One detail catches people out. The guidance says an agreement with a third party to monitor your reviews does not remove your own duties. Paying for a review widget does not hand your legal responsibility to the software company. If you are planning to add reviews to your website, set up the policy and process at the same time as the widget, not afterwards.
Has the CMA actually enforced the fake review ban yet?
The CMA's March 2026 announcement sets out the concerns, and they map neatly onto everyday small business habits:
- Autotrader and Feefo: whether one-star reviews moderated by Feefo were kept off Autotrader and excluded from star ratings.
- Dignity: whether staff were asked to write favourable reviews of its crematoria.
- Just Eat: whether its ratings system inflated star ratings for some restaurants and grocers.
- Pasta Evangelists: whether customers were offered discounts on future orders for five-star reviews on delivery apps without that being disclosed.
Read that list again as a small business owner. Hiding bad reviews, asking staff to post, presenting a flattering average and rewarding only top ratings are the four temptations most local firms face.
The same announcement reports that 75% of the firms contacted said they better understood the rules afterwards. Sarah Cardell, the CMA's chief executive, put it bluntly: "We've given businesses the time to get things right."
How big are the fines for fake reviews?
The CMA's April 2025 release also lists penalties of up to 5% of global turnover for breaching undertakings, and up to 1% for withholding information or providing false information during an investigation. It added that fines in the first 12 months were likely to be lower because the powers could not apply retrospectively.
For a small firm, the bigger cost is often not the fine. It is the time spent answering a regulator, the forced changes to how you collect feedback, and the reputational hit of being named publicly.
Can you still ask customers for reviews?
A clean review request looks like this: a short text or email sent to every customer after a completed job, a direct link to your Google profile, and no mention of star ratings. "How did we do? Your honest feedback helps other local customers" is fine. "Leave us five stars and get £5 off" is close to the conduct the CMA is looking at in the Pasta Evangelists case.
Are staff, friends and family reviews allowed?
The practical line is simple. If your sister genuinely bought a service and paid for it, her experience is real, but the connection should be obvious or she should not post. If staff are asked, encouraged or rewarded to write glowing reviews, stop. A quiet word at a team meeting costs nothing and removes one of the most common risks for local businesses.
What do you need to do to comply?
The CMA's short guide covers those four areas. Here is how they translate for a small business with a website and a Google profile:
- Write a one-page review policy. State that fake reviews are prohibited, explain whether you ever offer incentives and how they are labelled, and say how you handle the reviews you display. Link it from the footer near your testimonials.
- Assess your risk. Where do reviews come from, who can post them, and where are you tempted to cut corners? The guidance says this is "not a one-off exercise", so revisit it when you change tools or launch a referral offer.
- Set a simple process. Decide who checks new reviews, what counts as suspicious (a burst of reviews from new accounts, identical wording), and what you do about it.
- Show the whole picture. If your website displays an average rating, it should reflect the full set, not a hand-picked selection.
Writing honest, prompt replies to negative feedback is part of the same discipline. If complaints are piling up faster than you can answer them, this guide to AI complaint handling for UK businesses can help you respond consistently without drafting every reply from scratch.
What should you do about fake reviews of your business?
Do not fight fire with fire. Countering a wave of fake one-star reviews with fake five-star ones turns you from the target into the offender. A short public reply such as "We can't find a booking under this name, please contact us directly so we can look into it" tells future customers more than a defensive essay. If you suspect a coordinated campaign, you can also report it to the CMA.
Is it worth auditing your reviews now?
Open your Google profile and website side by side. Check that your displayed rating matches reality, that any incentivised reviews are labelled, that your request templates go to every customer, and that a policy is live. Keep a note of what you checked and when. That record is your evidence of "reasonable and proportionate steps" if anyone ever asks.
For businesses handling a high volume of enquiries, folding review requests into an existing follow-up flow keeps the process consistent. The guide to AI customer service for UK small businesses covers how to automate that kind of routine contact without losing the personal tone. For the wider picture of building a review profile that holds up, see the reviews service hub.
Fake Reviews and the DMCC Act — FAQ
Is it illegal to post fake reviews in the UK?
Yes. The Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 contains an explicit ban on posting and commissioning fake reviews, and the CMA confirmed the new consumer protection provisions came into force in April 2025. The ban covers more than writing a review yourself. Paying someone else to write one, hiding the fact that a review was incentivised, and publishing star ratings or review counts that are misleading because they rely on fake content all fall within the CMA's guidance. Small businesses get no exemption. If you publish reviews anywhere, including on your own website, the rules apply to you.
How much can the CMA fine a business for fake reviews?
Under the DMCC Act regime, the CMA can fine a business up to 10% of its global turnover for breaching consumer protection law, and it no longer needs to go through the courts first. The CMA said fines in the first 12 months would likely be lower because its powers could not be applied to conduct before the rules started. That early window has now closed. For a small business, the real risk is less about the maximum figure and more about an investigation, enforced changes, refunds and the damage to trust if a case becomes public.
Can I offer customers a discount for leaving a review?
You can incentivise reviews, but you must not hide the incentive. The CMA's short guide lists concealed incentivised reviews as banned content, meaning reviews written in exchange for money or a free benefit without making that clear. Offering a discount only for five-star reviews is the riskier version. In March 2026 the CMA opened an investigation into whether Pasta Evangelists offered discounts on future orders for five-star reviews without disclosing it. The safer approach is to offer any incentive for honest feedback regardless of rating, label those reviews clearly, and state your approach in a published review policy.
Does a small business that only uses Google reviews need a review policy?
If you publish reviews or star ratings on your own website, social pages or marketing, the CMA expects you to take reasonable steps to prevent banned content, and a published policy that clearly prohibits fake reviews and explains how you handle incentivised ones is the simplest way to show that. When the CMA checked more than 100 review publishers, it wrote to 54 firms about gaps in their approach. If you never republish reviews and only receive them on Google, Google carries the platform duties, but you are still banned from writing, buying or commissioning fake reviews there.
What should I do if a competitor leaves fake reviews on my profile?
Report the review through the platform's own flagging tool, keep screenshots with dates, and reply calmly in public without accusing anyone by name. Under the CMA guidance, the platform hosting the review is responsible for preventing and removing banned content, so the report is your main lever. If a pattern of fake negative reviews looks clearly coordinated, you can also report it to the CMA. Resist the urge to counter with fake positive reviews of your own, because that turns you from the victim into the one breaking the law.



